
Almost done! Please Select Your Region To Receive Customized Content
Select Your Region
Your information is safe and secure with us
A share buyback (or share repurchase) happens when a company uses its own cash to buy back its own shares. Buying back shares increases earnings per share (EPS). This means share prices theoretically should increase and benefit shareholders. But the question is… does it truly benefit shareholders?
Warren Buffet preaches share buybacks as a tax efficient way of returning capital back to shareholders, therefore his favourite companies often buy back shares in large amounts.
However, one must note that his investments are predominantly in the U.S. In the U.S, dividends are taxable, hence companies issuing dividends are double taxed, once at the corporate level and once more as dividends to shareholders. It is tax efficient to buy back shares for U.S-based companies because share buy-backs are not taxable and share prices should rise if EPS increases, returning capital back to shareholders.
Share buybacks are also a vote of confidence that the management is confident that shares of the company are underpriced and they believe the company will grow further.
However, Warren Buffet also warned of recent abuse of share buybacks where management uses it as a method of propping up falling share prices or issuing large stock options for themselves while buying back shares. These are cases where share buybacks hurt investors more than benefit them.
Returning back to Singapore, there is no equivalent dividend tax for Singapore-listed companies. This makes dividends a very efficient method of distributing back cash to shareholders if the company is unable to invest in their core business for good returns.
Nonetheless, many companies in Singapore still hop on the same bandwagon as U.S companies and engage in active share buybacks instead of dividends. Such share buybacks could actually be harmful to long-term shareholders because if the buybacks are executed at high prices, it is essentially throwing money away to traders and short-term investors who cash out at these higher prices.
Noble Group is a prime example where share buybacks may not necessarily be beneficial for its shareholders. Noble’s share price was under attack when Iceberg Research’s report of alleged accounting fraud was released, sending share prices into a freefall from a high of $1.21 in February to its current price of $0.58 per share as of 6 Aug 2015. From 12 June to 27 July, Noble repurchased 191 million shares, spending $131m at an average price of $0.68 per share.
Noble Group’s falling share price during its share buyback. Source: Yahoo! Finance
When Noble initiated the share buybacks, Noble’s shares were trading at 0.7 times book value. Noble Group CEO Yusuf Alireza believed that the company was deeply undervalued.
Indeed, compared to Wilmar and Olam, it may be deeply undervalued based on P/B alone. Yet, the shares plunged by 8 cents to $0.52 on 30 July, declining 12% in a single day! As of 3 Aug, at $0.47, it was trading at 0.44 P/B, a 30.8% decline in value of the shares it bought back. Suddenly the repurchase price of $0.68 didn’t look as cheap as the management claimed to be.
Even though it is indeed cheap based on price-to-book value, it assumes that the assets are truly worth the amount. As accused by Iceberg Research Group, if Yancoal and other assets are mispriced on Noble’s balance sheet, it will have a significant misguiding effect on the P/B ratio.
Noble Group’s P/B. Source: Stockflock.co
Noble also has high debt ($2.6 billion long-term debt and $11.2 billiion in accounts payable) and negative operating cash flow. It is not particularly convincing that using cash for share buybacks is the best use of capital. Aggressive share buybacks could threaten Noble’s credit rating, causing the cost of debt to increase and further hurt share prices.
Noble Group’s debt/equity ratio. Source: Stockflock.co
Noble Group’s operating cash flow. Source: Stockflock.co
The nature of a commodity trading business is capital intensive as it needs to carry large inventory, hence the company is reliant on short-term financing from bank loans and suppliers (as evident by the $11.2 billion in accounts payable). Should its credit rating drop, even a small increase in financing cost will be a significant burden on Noble’s balance sheet or even trigger margin calls. On June 11, Noble Group was put on notice by credit agency Standard & Poors of being at risk to being downgraded to junk status, revising its outlook to negative while maintaining a BBB- rating.
Noble shares have slightly rebounded to $0.58 from possible hints of suitors and short-covering — a situation where short sellers buy shares to take profit. But that still represents a loss of 14.7% from the repurchased shares. Only time will tell if the share buybacks will eventually generate good value for investors as what management claims. As of now, the repurchased shares are sitting on a 14.7% loss in value. One should note that Noble is also the most shorted company in the STI, with 9.7% of outstanding shares are with short interest. Therefore, investors should not assume share buybacks are definitely good for investors!
While share buybacks might be temporary relief for share prices in the short run, buying back shares at overvalued prices will only hurt shareholders in the long run. In fact, share buybacks could be a red flag that management’s and long-term shareholders’ interests are not aligned.
To monitor a company’s share buybacks, you can go to the SGX website and look under company announcements or ShareInvestor’s share buyback feature (though you need to be a subscriber). Alternatively, you can use Stockflock to customize a portfolio to monitor a company’s share buybacks.
So although share buybacks usually signal that a company sees no better investment other than itself, it may not always be true. If a company uses buybacks to prop up its ratios and bring short-term relief to its falling share price… watch out!
Get up to speed with this Quick-Start Manual that'll show you how to be profitable in the stock market - Written in simple English that's extremely easy to understand, yet packs plenty of valuable profit strategies every investor must know...
Get up to speed with this Quick-Start Manual that'll show you how to be profitable in the stock market - Written in simple English that's extremely easy to understand, yet packs plenty of valuable profit strategies every investor must know
Get up to speed with this Quick-Start Manual that'll show you how to be profitable in the stock market - Written in simple English that's extremely easy to understand, yet packs plenty of valuable profit strategies every investor must know
Get up to speed with this Quick-Start Manual that'll show you how to be profitable in the stock market - Written in simple English that's extremely easy to understand, yet packs plenty of valuable profit strategies every investor must know
Select Your Country
This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.
How to buy shares in Malaysia and open a Malaysian brokerage account
How to open a brokerage account in Singapore (and choose the right broker)
An open letter to our readers who want to win the game of stocks
Why we will be rejecting ARA Asset Management’s privatization offer of $1.78 per share
Top 10 Singapore REITs that made you money if you invested from their IPOs (updated 2019)
30 years from now: how much your lifestyle will cost in 2047
4 reasons why property may not be the best asset for retirement
How to start investing in Singapore: A practical guide for beginners (updated 2019)
6 ways to reduce your monthly expenses… without compromising on your lifestyle
MyEG Services has crashed over 70% since the Malaysian election… what now?
Top 10 Singapore REITs that made you money if you invested from their IPOs (updated 2019)
10 things to know about Frasers Logistics Trust before you invest (updated 2019)
5 key things I learned from Facebook’s Q4 2018 earnings call
10 things I learned from the 2019 Frasers Centrepoint Trust AGM
11 things to know about KLCC Stapled Group before you invest
8 timeless quotes from Warren Buffett about life, business and investing
Money FM 89.3 – U.S. share buybacks hit $1 trillion in 2018, will the trend continue this year?
13 things to know about Frasers Commercial Trust before you invest (updated 2019)
How to open a brokerage account in Singapore (and choose the right broker)
How to start investing in Singapore: A practical guide for beginners (updated 2019)
The Fifth Person believes in spreading a message -- that sound investment knowledge, financial literacy and intelligent money habits can help millions of people around the world achieve financial security, freedom, and lead better lives for themselves and their loved ones.
Our company and the knowledge we share here is born of that vision. So take a tour around the site and read our articles. We hope that the good stuff we have here will lead to smarter, more profitable investment decisions for you and the world at large.
This is neither a recommendation to purchase or sell any of the shares, securities or other instruments mentioned in this document or referred to; nor can this course material and/or document be treated as professional advice to buy, sell or take a position in any shares, securities or other instruments. The information contained herein is based on the study and research of the Fifth Person Pte Ltd (“the Authors”); and are merely the written opinions and ideas of the Authors, and is as such strictly for educational purposes and/or for study or research only.
This information should not and cannot be construed as or relied on and (for all intents and purposes) does not constitute financial, investment or any other form of advice. Any investment involves the taking of substantial risks, including (but not limited to) complete loss of capital. Every investor has different strategies, risk tolerances and time frames. You are advised to perform your own independent checks, research or study; and you should contact a licensed professional before making any investment decisions.
Copyright © 2019 The Fifth Person. All rights reserved.
Almost done! Please complete this form and click the button below to subscribe
Enter your email address to receive FREE weekly investment insights, stock analysis, case studies & more!
Your information is safe and secure with us
Almost done! Please complete this form and click the button below to subscribe
Enter your email address to receive FREE weekly investment insights, stock analysis, case studies & more!
Your information is safe and secure with us
mazuki karim
August 12, 2015 at 1:15 pm
Very inspiring and refresh my outlooks on share investments .tq
Wilson
August 16, 2015 at 2:17 am
Hi Karim,
Thank you for your comments. They are well-appreciated.
Sincerely,
Wilson